Stop second-guessing yourself. Clarity Under Pressure  3-week workshop to build confidence under pressure. Open Now!

What Makes a Community Worth Coming Back To?

November 3, 2026

After being part of more than 18 communities, I’m learning what makes me want to stay.

Photo by fauxels

Over the past three years, I’ve been part of more than 18 communities, which sounds like quite a lot now that I’ve actually counted them. It’s been a mix of online and in person, covering everything from business development and AI to coaching, wellbeing, and groups connected to everyday life. Some I’m still really involved in. Others I’ve drifted away from or made a decision to leave.

When I say community, I mean a group connected by a shared interest, purpose, or experience, where there’s an ongoing opportunity to interact and build relationships. I’m including both paid and free memberships here, although most of mine have been paid.

Being part of that many different groups has given me plenty to think about. Why do I look forward to spending time in one, while another starts to feel like something I should be making more effort with? What makes me want to get involved, and what makes me slowly stop showing up?

Feeling like these are my people

One community I’m involved in has become a big part of my life, and a lot of that comes down to how I feel about the people.

I can meet someone from this group and know absolutely nothing about their work, but because we’re both members, we already have somewhere to start. There’s a level of trust there. Within two minutes, we can be into the juicy stuff, talking honestly about what we’re doing and what we’re figuring out.

That hasn’t happened by accident. The community has become really clear about its purpose and who it’s for, and there’s thought behind how people are brought into it.

We’re not all doing the same thing or at the same stage. Everyone is building, learning, sharing, or experiencing something, and our journeys overlap enough that we can help each other.

The relationships carry on between events, too. There are texts, introductions, coffee dates, and genuine support. I enjoy being around these people, and that makes a big difference.

When I started feeling behind

I’ve also had the experience of logging into a community and feeling my heart sink.

There would be a calendar full of things I was interested in, but not enough time to participate in all of them. I’d see conversations happening and struggle to find my way into them. Sometimes I’d get on a call and realize I wasn’t following because I hadn’t been at the previous one.

Every visit seemed to remind me how much I’d missed. The teaching could be useful, but I wasn’t enjoying being there, and eventually that became part of my decision to leave. I’ve left another community for similar reasons. I wasn’t getting value from spending my time there anymore.

There are only so many things I can give my attention to. If participating means constantly catching up, I have to ask whether it fits my life.

What am I getting from being here?

Money is a consideration for sure, but I’m finding that, for me, time and energy play an even bigger role. I need to feel that what I’m getting from my communities is worth what I’m putting in.

At this stage in my journey, I want to learn something and actually use it. I want to try an idea, have a useful conversation, or move something forward in my business. I also want to have fun, engage with like-minded people, and enjoy supporting each other.

My level of involvement will vary. I can be right in the middle of one community and around the edges of another, and still get something valuable from both. What matters is whether that way of participating works for me.

The Rewriters Room annual membership offer: $175 through December 31, 2026.

What we’re building in the Rewriters Room

The Rewriters Room is for people building something, navigating what it asks of them, and wanting thoughtful company along the way.

That includes creators and entrepreneurs getting started, as well as people with established businesses who are figuring out what comes next.

You might be considering a change in direction, trying to explain your vision to someone you want to bring on board, or working out how your role needs to change as the business grows. These are practical questions, but they ask something of us personally, too.

Jen Benford✨ and I bring AI, branding, and mindset into those conversations. We bring some of our own experience and we also bring in lots of brilliant leaders in their field to share with us on their topics and frameworks. We connect people with relevant experience, make introductions, and give space to members to bring their own knowledge, questions, and perspectives, so the learning comes from across the group.

We want people to bring a real question, hear another perspective, and find something useful to put into practice. And we want room for connections, honest conversations, and a bit of banter as we grow what we’re building with intention, purpose, and joy.

If that sounds like your kind of room, come have a look. Our Founding Member Launch price is $175 for the full year. Choose Annual when you join.

What makes you want to come back to a community?

Stef Hingley | Inner Edge Coaching | stef@stefaniehingley.com

Originally published on Inner Edge Coaching on Substack, November 3, 2026.

Stefanie Hingley

I'm on a journey to empower people to take intentional steps towards growth, balance and fulfillment in their lives. I write about things that inspire and serve me and hope they serve you too!